A whole scene with no chart
There was no grime chart and no way to filter for women in grime. A grime artist couldn't stand out in the charts, and a grime fan couldn't browse the best of the scene.
A discovery problem on both sides
When a subgenre has no category, creators can't stand out and listeners can't dig in. Fewer plays mean lower royalties, so niche artists find it harder to turn a passion into a career. I called this the symbiotic discovery problem: creators and fans lose out together.
Start small: open-design charts
- Propose and vote
Creators and fans suggest niche chart categories and vote on them, using Instagram Story tags where the scenes already talk.
- Add the label and the chart
Each winning subgenre gets a label and a playlist with two filters: all-time best and this month's hot releases.
- Test before building more
Launch, measure and only then join the new labels up to search, the home feed and generated playlists.
A learning community, hiding in plain sight
Longer term, I saw SoundCloud as a space where musicians and other creators connect and co-create releases before they go out to a wider network of partners. Subgenre labels decided by the community would be its foundation. Where the labels mean something to a local culture, they could also shape local charts.
Ship the smallest change that tests the biggest assumption
Then → Now
Then: I wrote it as a job pitch. Now: I'd lead with the evidence and the test plan, and keep the vision short.
Then → Now
Then: Categories decided by the platform. Now: categories proposed by the community. The same idea runs through my later creator-economy work.
Then → Now
Then: One genre example. Now: I'd test across several scenes before generalising.